< Back to Blogs Index

783: NIC chair resigns

News and ViewsBlogsPlanning Act 2008783: NIC chair resigns
783: NIC chair resigns
2 Comments Angus Walker

By Angus Walker

Today’s entry reports on the resignation of Lord Adonis from the National Infrastructure Commission.

On 29 December Lord (Andrew) Adonis tendered his resignation as Chair of the National Infrastructure Commission (NIC) to the Prime Minister, Theresa May MP (even though technically the Chancellor, Philip Hammond MP, appointed him). The full resignation letter can be found on the BBC website.

His main ‘fundamental difference’ with the government is over Brexit, but he also claims that the Virgin Stagecoach East Coast Main Line rail franchise is being allowed to end early, costing the taxpayer hundreds of millions of pounds, something the government denies. Perhaps the final straw was the effective withdrawal of an invitation to the DfT’s annual reception (see the end of this Guardian article).

He is the second commissioner of the NIC to leave, the first being Lord Heseltine, who was sacked in March 2017 after voting against the government on the European Union (Notification of Withdrawal) Bill. He supported an amendment requiring a Parliamentary vote on the final deal, recently the subject of a defeat in the Commons, albeit as part of a different Bill.

So far, then, membership of both the House of Lords and the National Infrastructure Commission have proven incompatible.

The resignation prompted me to check the NIC’s charter, which can be found here. It says ‘The NIC will operate independently, at arm’s length from government…’, but it seems that there are limits to that independence (or the length of the arm).

The current deputy chair, Sir John Armitt, is likely to take on the role of chair in the interim, if not permanently, and the NIC’s work will continue as planned.

Happy new year to all our readers! 2018 predictions and the results of the Christmas champagne competition will be announced in the next blog entry (unless some other hold-the-front-page news occurs).

5 January 2018


  • Clinton Leeks says:

    Lord Adonis is a huge loss. But we are lucky to have someone of Sir John Armitt’s calibre to fill the gap

    • Company Name: Cleeks OBE Consultancy Ltd
  • Peter George says:

    Lord Adonis’s departure is a disappointment although his dogged determination to reverse Brexit has, I fear, become all consuming to the point he can focus on nothing else (except perhaps university vice chancellor’s pay).

    It seems these days that politicians in both houses are unable to put aside political ambition and get the job they have been given done. Adonis’s departure from the NIC will be felt but Sir John Armitt is more pragmatic so there’s hope the commission can still move things forward despite Brexit. Adonis has missed an opportunity for the sake of political posturing. Let’s hope Armitt does not do likewise.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *